Board Room Second Impressions

Written by:

I missed my post last week because I was in a board meeting. It made me reflect on the many boards I have worked with over the last decade and what I learned from them. The lessons here come from boards across my career, not from the board I serve now.

In August I wrote about Board First Impressions. The post listed five boardroom behaviors a new CEO should watch. The first is how the agenda balances strategic, generative, and operational work. The second is whether discussion is balanced. The third is how members handle disagreement. The fourth is whether the strategic plan guides their work. The fifth is what drives their decisions.

That post built on earlier ones about board assessment. Fitting the Personality of a Board asked whether a board’s style fits the leader. Building Relationships as a New Nonprofit Leader and The Listening Tour Starts Here covered the questions I ask board members in my first weeks.

This post goes deeper on behaviors two and three. What do you do when a few loud voices dominate the room? And what do you do when you can’t tell how the board handles disagreement?

Start with the board chair. The chair runs the meeting, not the CEO. Your role is to help the chair build facilitation skills and feel empowered to lead the room.

Chairs differ in how much help they want. Some welcome the CEO’s support with facilitation. Others prefer to run the room on their own. Ask before you assume.

When the same few people speak on every topic, quieter members stop trying. Their ideas never reach the table.

The simplest fix I know comes from early in my career at the National Academy of Sciences. Every member has a table tent with their name on it. When someone wants to speak, they turn the tent on its end. The chair writes down names in order, and everyone can see who is waiting.

I have used this in many boardrooms. Quieter members get into the queue without competing for the chair’s attention. People no longer raise their hands again and again, which tends to favor whoever is fastest. The chair can build a list five or six names deep and work through it, so the conversation moves around the whole table.

It costs nothing and takes a minute to explain.

The third behavior is harder to read. Silence in a board meeting can mean agreement. It can also mean people are not comfortable disagreeing in front of the full group.

For this, I go back to Liberating Structures. I wrote about the new fieldbook, and two meetings where I used it, in Forty-three Ways to Run a Better Meeting.

With boards, I start with small groups. Some people are more comfortable having an active discussion with two or three colleagues than with the full board. That holds even when the topic is not a disagreement.

When the small groups come back together, several ideas are on the table instead of one. That helps a board break out of its usual patterns.

A first impression is a starting point, not a verdict. Boards change when their meetings change. I have found that I partner well with board chairs on how to make meetings work. Table tents and small groups give you something concrete to bring to that conversation.

What have you tried that helped a quiet board find its voice, or got a few dominant members to share the floor?


Discover more from She Leads with Purpose

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply